Skip to main content

Open access publishing in medicine and health: deciding where to publish

By
by: Keith Nockels
Academic Librarian
Many research funders require you to publish the work they fund as an open access article (check SHERPA/JULIET to see if your funder does). Open access articles are freely available to all readers, with no need for a subscription or payment. This makes your work more widely available, and may increase its citation count.
In the traditional publishing model, the reader pays a subscription, or a fee to download an individual article. In the open access model, the reader pays nothing. To discuss how open access affects you as an author, and whether you will need to pay a fee, contact us for advice.


Created by Adrienne Yancey for opensource.com https://flic.kr/p/9LBN2U

 There are many reputable open access publishers, and many reputable “traditional” publishers offer an open access option. 
But publishing has a bad side too. There are publishers who charge a fee, promise great things, and deliver little. Some of them solicit articles by emailing people directly.    
I sometimes get emails, inviting me to write an article. Alarm bells ring if I am addressed wrongly (Dear Dr Nockels,) or not at all (Dear, ). Some of the emails are badly written or edited, and they often approach me for work in fields I am supposed to be an expert in but about which I know nothing. Some are from journals that cover a strange mix of subjects, like (fictional, probably) the “International Journal of Nutrition and Lunar Studies”. I suspect that if any reputable journal wanted me to write an invited article, it would approach me in a rather more personal way. Not that this has ever happened, yet, anyway…
These emails are, I strongly suspect, from “predatory” publishers. They may tell you their journal is widely indexed, when it is not, or that it is indexed in something that actually indexes everything. Sometimes the editorial boards include people who are named without their knowledge. Sometimes these journals ask you, the author, to suggest reviewers for your article, and do little to check the identity of that reviewer.
A BMJ Minerva column refers to a study reported in Nature, in which a Dr Anna O. Szust applied to a large number of “predatory” journals asking to be an editor. 48 out of the 360 accepted her and 4 of those made her editor in chief. Polish speakers among you (sadly I am not one) will spot that oszust means “fraud”.  
Some existing journals have been “hijacked” by predatory publishers and some predatory journals have titles so similar to the title of an existing, reputable journal, that you can be easily fooled.
If you have had such an email, or are worried about a journal that you are thinking of submitting to, here are some actions you can take.
·         Ask colleagues who have experience of being published and knowledge of which journals are the core ones.   
·         Use Think Check Submit checklist, when deciding where to submit.
·         Ask the Library – we can identify core journals, check the journal’s claims about where it is indexed and would be happy to investigate a journal you are thinking of submitting to.
·         This (open access) article by Hansoti, Langdorf and Murphy, in the Western Journal of Emergency Medicine includes criteria to help you distinguish legitimate from predatory open access journals.
·         The Minerva article mentioned above refers to an (open access) study in BMC Medicine, on how to tell the difference between a predatory and a legitimate biomedical journal.
·         The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors have published a news item about “Fake”, “Predatory” and “Pseudo” journals. It includes a definition of these types of journal, and reasons why they pose a threat and should be avoided.
·         The World Association of Medical Editors’ have guidance.
·         Use the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) to check the journal
This is based on articles I wrote for the University Hospitals of Leicester Writing Club Blog, by kind permission of Pip Divall, Clinical Librarian Service Manager.  If you work at University Hospitals of Leicester, do consider attending a Writing Club meeting.  Meetings are workshops, led by librarians or health practitioners, looking at a specific topic of interest and relevance to
people writing for publication.
Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

You can now export multiple citations from Google Scholar

By
You can now export multiple citations from Google Scholar if you have a Google Account. Go to Google Scholar and sign into your Google Account. Conduct your search. Click on the Star icon (Save) under each reference you want to export. Then click on My Library in the top, right of the screen. Select all the references and click on the Export option: Click the Star/Save Icon Choose Export Option To Export into EndNote Choose the EndNote option. Open the EndNote file that is created. The references should automatically import into EndNote. To Export into RefWorks Choose the RefMan option. Save the RIS file that is created. Login to your RefWorks account. Click on the plus (+) button. Choose Import References. Add the RIS file you just saved. Set the file import option to RIS - Reference Manager. Click import and your references will be imported. --- Good Practice Tip: Always check that all the reference information you need has been
Read more

Searching ABS Journals in Business Source Premier

By
In Business and Management Studies, researchers undertaking a literature review sometimes search across a defined group of journals. This is a way of focusing the literature search to make the results more relevant to the questions in hand. Groups are often chosen from the Association of Business Schools (ABS)'s  Academic Journal Guide . Read more how about how they put together the guide here . There are several ways to search across ABS journals. Here is how to do it in Business Source Premier, a leading literature database for this subject area.  1.     Login into the ABS journal guide. If you have never used it before you will need to create an account. 2.     You can use the guide to draw up a group of journals either by using the Rankings information or the Fields. Fields divides up the journals into categories of research focus e.g. Accounting, Finance etc. In this example we will use the Fields. The field we are interested is ‘Operations Research and Marketin
Read more

Advanced Search Tip: Proximity (Adjacency) Searching

By
Proximity (Adjacency) Searching vs Phrase Searching When you're searching literature databases you might want to find a phrase. The easiest way to do this is to put the phrase in "speech marks". E.g. "heart disease" This will find that exact phrase - with the words next to each other in that order. BUT... You may be interested in variations on that phrase e.g. heart disease, disease of the heart, diseases of the heart, diseases of the human heart. In that case it might be better to use a proximity/adjacency search - this allows you to find one keyword next to another. Or one keyword within a specified number of words of the other keyword. When using a proximity search the keywords can be in any order. Different Databases Use Different Proximity Operators In Ovid Medline : heart adj disease finds the word heart next to the word disease, in that order.    (This is the same as searching for the phrase, of course) heart adj2 disease fin
Read more